Robert Steele: Intelligent Management of Intelligence Agencies, and the New Craft of Intelligence

Robert David STEELE Vivas

I have begun drafting my portion of the new Handbook of Intelligence Studies (Routledge, 2013), it is a chapter early on entitled “The Craft of Intelligence.”  I pick up where Allen Dulles and Sherman Kent left off.  My graphic on Intelligence Maturity captures the essence of my thinking at the strategic level, but of course there is more to come, including the desperate need to restore integrity to all that we do.

In 1988 I ghost-wrote for the Commandant of  the Marine Corps an article that he enhanced and signed, “Global Intelligence Challenges in the 1990′s.”  At that time my focus was on the difference between the conventional threat and the emerging unconventional threat.

Now my focus is on the purpose and process of intelligence as decision-support.  We must — we will — move from secret intelligence for the few to open intelligence for the many; from expensive centralized largely worthless intelligence to free and low-cost distributed intelligence relevant to every person at every level on every issue; from intelligence as window-dressing for channeling $80 billion a year to banks and corporations, to intelligence as an integral element of every aspect of a Smart Nation.

Today Owl sent me a link to an article, Philip E. Tetlock and Barabara A Mellers, “Intelligent Management of Intelligence Agencies,” American Psychologist, 2011, pp. 1-12.  I  respect Owl, so I printed it and read it twice.

This article is completely out of touch with reality and the authors have not bothered to familiarize themselves with the literatures pertinent to their endeavor.  Out of 89 cited sources 12 are non-intelligence-related prior publications of the lead author, 1 is a prior publication of the second author, and 11 are ostensibly about intelligence but truly marginal selections.  So 12% sources on the subject, 13% self-citation, and 75% escoteric psycho-babble irrelevant to the actual challenge.  As an intelligence professional, I am offended that two ostensibly erudite individuals would dare to publish this trype without even a semblance of understanding of the subject under discussion.

See Also:

Robert Steele: The Craft of Intelligence – OLD vs. NEW

Here are a few comments and additional links:

Continue reading

In “borderless” cyberspace, nation states struggle — M4IS2 Anyone?

Click on Image to Enlarge

Analysis: In “borderless” cyberspace, nation states struggle

By Peter Apps, Political Risk Correspondent

Reuters LONDON | Thu Jun 9, 2011

EXTRACT:

“The nature of cyberspace is borderless and anonymous,” R. Chandrasekhara, secretary of India’s telecommunications department, told a cyber security conference in London last week organised by a U.S.-based think tank, the EastWest Institute. “Governments, countries and law — all are linked to territory. There is a fundamental contradiction.”

Read full article….

Tip of the Hat to Chris Pallaris at LinkedIn.

Phi Beta Iota: The national secret intelligence communities mean well, but they are cognitively and culturally incapacitated  in relation to both the global threats and the global infomation sharing and sense-making possibilities.  It may just be that the solution has to come from a private sector service of common concern that can provide the integrity now lacking in governments and most corporation.  Scary thought.  M4IS2 is inevitable….delay is costing trillions.

Link TV Educating Americans About Real World

John Steiner

Dear Friends far and wide:

Link TV in San Francisco is a precious resource for the progressive/transpartisan communities, and we¹re asking you to join us in making a gift to Link.

In December 1999, our good friend and colleague, Kim Spencer,
http://www.linktv.org/whoweare/staff launched Link TV, the first nationwide television network dedicated to providing Americans with global perspectives on news, events and culture. In the wake of media consolidation. Americans have little access to diverse perspectives on critical global issues, and Link challenges this trend.  Today, Link is now broadcast into 35 million homes across the US (largely through DISH, DIRECT TV and with some cable outlets), has 6.7 million regular viewers (many across the political and cultural divides), and provides coverage not found anywhere else in the US.

Link is the only US provider of Al Jazeera English, broadcasts Amy Goodman’s Democracy Now! daily, and has won a Peabody Award for its Middle East news program, Mosaic.

Continue reading

Whole Earth Review Archives on Public Intelligence (Historical)

1992

US

Whole Earth R Brand Army Green

1992

US

Whole Earth R Kapor et al We Need a National Public Network

1992

US

Whole Earth R Kleiner The Co-Evolution of Governance

1992

US

Whole Earth R Petersen Will the Military Miss the Market

1992

US

Whole Earth R Staple & Dixon Telegeography: Mapping the New World Order

1992

US

Whole Earth R Steele E3i: Ethics, Ecology, Evolution, and Intelligence

1992

US

Whole Earth R Tibbs Industrial Ecology: An Environmental Agenda for Industry

1991

US

Whole Earth R Brilliant Computer Conferencing: The Global Connection

1991

US

Whole Earth R Clay Genes, Genius, and Genocide

1991

US

Whole Earth R Elgin Conscious Democracy Through Electronic Town Meetings

1991

US

Whole Earth R Garcia Assessing the Impacts of Technology

1991

US

Whole Earth R Godwin The Electronic Frontier Foundation and Virtual Communities

1991

US

Whole Earth R Karraker Highways of the Mind

1991

US

Whole Earth R Lovins & Lovins Winning the Peace

1991

US

Whole Earth R Marx Privacy & Technology

1991

US

Whole Earth R Meeks The Global Commons

1991

US

Whole Earth R Rheingold Electronic Democracy: The Great Equalizer

1991

US

Whole Earth R Schuman Reclaiming our Technological Future

1991

US

Whole Earth R Warren & Rheingold Access to Political Tools: Effective Citizen Action

1991

US

Whole Earth R White Earthtrust: Electronic Mail and Ecological Activism

1991

US

Whole Earth R Whitney-Smith Information Doesn’t Want

1991

US

Whole Earth R Wittig Electronic City Hall

1990

US

Whole Earth R Barlow Crime and Puzzlement: The Advance of the Law on the Electronic Frontier

1990

US

Whole Earth R Brand Outlaws, Musicians, Lovers, and Spies: The Future of Control

1990

US

Whole Earth R Dodge Life Work

1990

JP

Whole Earth R Ishii Cross-Cultural Communications & Computer-Supported Cooperative Work

1990

US

Whole Earth R Jordon III Restoration: Shaping the Land, Transforming the Spirit

1990

JP

Whole Earth R Kumon Toward Co-Emulation: Japan and the United States in the Information Age

1990

US

Whole Earth R Monschke How to Heal the Land

1990

US

Whole Earth R Shapard Observations on Cross-Cultural Electronic Networking

1990

US

Whole Earth R Vidal Founding Father Knows Best

1989

US

Whole Earth R Berman The Gesture of Balance

1989

US

Whole Earth R Garfinkle Social Security Numbers: And Other Telling Information

1989

US

Whole Earth R Haight Living in the Office

1989

US

Whole Earth R Horvitz The USENET Underground

1989

US

Whole Earth R Jaffe Hello, Central: Phone Conferencing Tips

1989

US

Whole Earth R Johnson` The Portable Office

1989

US

Whole Earth R Rheingold Ethnobotany: The Search for Vanishing Knowledge

1988

US

Whole Earth R Baker, S. Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Baker, W. Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Brand The Information Wants to Be Free Strategy

1988

US

Whole Earth R Coate Tales from Two Communities: The Well and the Farm

1988

US

Whole Earth R Ferguson Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Fields Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Hardin Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Hawkins Computer Parasites & Remedies–A Catalog of First Sightings

1988

US

Whole Earth R Keen Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Kleiner Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Leary Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Nelson Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Newroe Distance Learning

1988

US

Whole Earth R Pert The Material Basis of Emotions with Inset, Mind as Information

1988

US

Whole Earth R Rappaport Gossip

1988

US

Whole Earth R Thurow & Walsh Getting Over the Information Economy

1987

US

Whole Earth R Donaldson An Incomplete History of Microcomputing

1987

US

Whole Earth R Henson MEMETICS: The Science of Information Viruses

1987

US

Whole Earth R Horvitz An Intelligent Guide to Intelligence

1987

US

Whole Earth R Krause Bio-Acoustics: Habitat Ambience & Ecological Balance

1987

US

Whole Earth R Roberts Electronic Cottage on Wheels

1986

US

Whole Earth R Fend & Gunther What Have You Got to Hide: Iraq Iran Basra Abadan

1986

US

Whole Earth R Minsky Society of Mind

1986

US

Whole Earth R Sanders Etiquette for the Age of Transparency

1986

US

Whole Earth R Scxhwartz & Brand The World Information Economy

1986

US

Whole Earth R Thompson A Gaian Politics

1985

US

Whole Earth R Brand, Kelly, Kinney Digital Retouching: The End of Photography as Evidence of Anything

1985

US

Whole Earth R Hunter Public Image

1985

US

Whole Earth R Kleiner The Health Hazards of Computers: A Guide to Worrying Intelligently

1985

US

Whole Earth R Mander Six Grave Doubts About Computers

1983

US

Whole Earth R Illich Silence is a Commons: Computers Are Doing to Communication What …

1982

US

Whole Earth R Brand Uncommon Courtesy: A School of Compassionate Skills

1982

US

Whole Earth R Kayes Force Without Power: A Doctrine of Unarmed Military Service

1982

US

Whole Earth R Meadows Whole Earth Models & Systems